Why Your Comments Section Should Be Like A Forum
Comments on your recent work or a guest post are the quickest and probably one of the most reliable ways of gauging your readers reaction. Most of the sites that belong to the readers of this site accept comments and encourage them.
I love the readers of this site, it really feels like a proper community on here and to quote Heather ”Nice to see so much of our little family”, it really does feel like a gathering of friends on here and as such it creates real value to the individual posts and to the site as a whole.
Comments bring traffic which in turn brings more comments;
- Help
Provide as much help as you can to each of the readers that contribute and reply to everything (within reason) if someone asks a question answer it, ask questions yourself. By doing all this you encourage conversation between you and your readers, which in turn will encourage conversation between readers and other readers.
I get a lot of my motivation from the readers of this site which is all down to the comments. If you look at the amount of comments that have been published on this site 3,533 at the time of writing, but looking at Karen’s guest post which has actually showing only 12 comments have been made, you would think there maybe a bug in my comments system. WordPress is only showing 12 ‘original’ comments if you like, the rest totalling 39 comments at the time of writing are replies.
- Love
Conversation and debate create a lot of comments, but by showing the love for those comments you create a friendly atmosphere for people to leave a comment and engage in the debate, no matter how intense it is. I very rarely comment on a guest post that’s on this site, mostly down to me wanting the guest poster to get maximum benefit from it, but if I’m honest there is no need for me to get involved as the guest poster and the readers of that post know they can comment and get a reply.
This may seem a little wishy washy, a bit too true hugger, but by creating a loving environment for your readers in the comments section, you can really up your chances of getting a lot of comments every month. As I said at the start comments bring traffic, traffic brings more comments, it’s a great cycle to be in.
Quick one if you are wondering how comments bring traffic, most of the time someone who comments will spread your content for you using social media, not always, but most of the time. By commenting they are engaged in your site and more likely to tell others about it.
- Benefit
Another way of creating a mini forum at the end of each of your posts is to give them some benefit. Commentluv, if you are not using this then (in my opinion) you’re missing out big time. Commentluv is the plugin which lets you leave a link back to your site when you comment on this post. A lot of sites use disqus to allow comments etc, now I maybe wrong here, but I have never seen a disqus comment space that allows a visible post link with your comment, something in which people can read and think ‘cool title’. Although I’m not sure if the two can be used together.
On this site you will see the top ten commenters too, I’m actually thinking of increasing this to the top 15 because so many people have contributed so many times, but just look at how many times those people have commented, they get links to their site everytime.
Readers who take the time to add value to your content deserve some benefit, so you should give it to them in bags.
You are nothing without your readers and as such you need to look after them. They in turn will look after each other which creates a community. Sure you will get people disagreeing but good ‘usually’ comes out of that.
Have you got a forum-like community on your site?
What does everyone think?
Please Comment and Conect
Please Re-Tweet, Digg and StumbleUpon
Tagged with: comments section • like a forum
Filed under: Blogging • Starting Out • Useful
Like this post? Subscribe to my RSS feed and get loads more!


Twitter: marenkate
says:
I agree… I notice much more traction & stickiness of my blog when true forums break out in the comments… it helps build a community around your blog & your personal brand.
Cheers!
Maren Kate´s last blog ..Viral Marketing: The Pickle that has 91,944 Facebook Fans
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Maren,
Yeah you’re absolutely right, having a community is great. It’s good to swap ideas etc, do you get much inspiration from your comments?
Twitter: Giveabrick
says:
Hi Maren

Do you think forums are still as popular as they once were?
Eleanor Edwards´s last blog ..Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
I would be interested in Maren’s thoughts on this too.
Twitter: Giveabrick
says:
I saw you’d posted this as a result of a tweet from Ian so just goes to show that social media works
I find this discussion very interesting because we had a forum at GAB for a short time. Whilst we weren’t getting the traffic we get now, the forum was dead. We’ve found people to be far more likely to engage via the comment option than in a forum (where users invariably must register before posting.)
I’ll be interested to see what happens to your comments when your forum gets going.
Eleanor Edwards´s last blog ..Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hi Eleanor, yeah it’s always easy for people to comment that to join a forum so that’s prob why you get more comments on your main site, in regards to my forum, it’s actually going to be invite only so the comments are (I would think) stay the same because the forum is actually on another site and can’t be joined or viewed unless I specifically send out an invite.
Social media does work though, absolutely
Twitter: TylinaVespart
says:
Oooo I was quoted… It’s true though, this place is rapidly turning into a second family of sorts. Always fun to just stop by and comment, see what everyone else has to say, and so on.
I think you’re right though – if there wasn’t this atmosphere I’d probably still be lurking even now. It’s a great thing you have here James, and I hope my blog’s as successful someday

Heather´s last blog ..The New Direction: Mission Plan
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
someday… someday, you should be aiming for it to be next week, tomorrow, right now even! You have done a fantastic job with the new site and your comments reflect that, some big hitters taking notice of you already!
I have posted it on your site but I have an invite for you that’ll send out next week to my forum which is by invitation only.
Twitter: TylinaVespart
says:
I have plans
Just watching to see how they pan out… Thank you James
You’ve been a huge source of inspiration and encouragement throughout all this!
As I said on my site, I’m looking forward to it! If you want/need any help let me know, I’ve actually assisted in running forums before on different subjects.
Heather´s last blog ..The New Direction: Mission Plan
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Cool I’ve got one mod already looking for another two or three so will take you up on that I think
Twitter: TylinaVespart
says:
Awesome – let me know what you decide.

Heather´s last blog ..The New Direction: Mission Plan
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Will do, the ‘founding’ members will be limited and specially chosen so it’s going to be an exciting place to be.
Twitter: TylinaVespart
says:
Yep, I’m willing to bet it’ll grow into something magical… Best of luck setting it up

Heather´s last blog ..The New Direction: Mission Plan
Twitter: bluepop13
says:
Comments should not only add value but also should act like forums I agree. My blog is beginning to get some of this to it though for some reason threaded comments don’t do good on mine. Not sure why. I think my design is causing me some productivity issues.
Good post and I feel the same way here as Heather, it’s like we’re all a family and come together all over the day to talk to one another.
Give me a warm and fuzzy!

Eric´s last blog ..Real Or Robot
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
oorrrrrrrr high fives all round, go team!
Twitter: kruby
says:
I emailed you about this, Eric.
Theaded comments are very important so that they allow people to see the entire conversation and are able to Reply back to the specific comments. IMHO, you should be looking to fix this design flaw on your site. Surely there is a support forum where others have posted the same issue?
Karen´s last blog ..Why It’s Never Too Late For Your Dreams To Come True
Twitter: markotu
says:
I’d just like to let you know about Disqus. I’m using Disqus comment system and unfortunately you can’t use any other comment plugin at the same time (no CommentLuv, no DoFollow,…). The two can’t be used together. It has other benefits tho’.
Marko´s last blog ..50 Beautiful Butterfly Pictures
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Marko,
Yeah that’s what I thought, what are the benefits of it? I’m interested as I very nearly went down that route but the wordpress threaded comments with Akismet and commentluv seems to do the trick
Twitter: markotu
says:
I like Disqus because it allows me to manage comments for all my blogs from one place. Threaded comments look better. There’s a nice sidebar widget for Disqus. You can see on what other blogs your commenters comment. And some other little things.
Marko´s last blog ..50 Beautiful Butterfly Pictures
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Marko,
Interesting stuff man, I wish the two would get together so you could incorporate commentluv. Sounds like a good tool, I’m a slave to commentluv though lol
Twitter: segedoo
says:
commenting is most beneficial if people engage in a dialogue. i noticed that only a few people interact with other people on most posts after the author and the commentator have “spoken.”
It will be more community like if we all talk woth each other instead of the author-commentator thingy.
Cheers
Olusegun´s last blog ..Blogging Lessons from Hip Hop Artistes
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hi Olusegun,
I think that does happen here, people do reply to other peoples replies, just look at your latest one to jordan as an example. I get what you mean, but I think that does happen here.
Twitter: TylinaVespart
says:
Have to agree with you there Olusegan – though I’ll admit to being a little guilty of that myself. It’s mostly because I don’t really want to hijack other people’s comments; I’ll quite often sit and read them though.
Heather´s last blog ..The New Direction: Mission Plan
Twitter: KiwiGordie
says:
I think more people need to check the notify of followup comments via email box. That would get more people coming back to reply to the replies to their comments. Disqus does this by default.
Here’s a suggestion about your most active commenters. You could try setting this to start again at the beginning of each month, so it would be “Most active commenters this month”. As your blog ages, new people coming here will have almost no chance of catching up with the old-timers. Just an idea.
Gordie´s last blog ..You’re A Bad Parent If …
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Yeah it’s funny I was thinking about doing this, I think for now though I’ll keep it like that, I have increased the number shown, but you’re right it’s definately worth bearing in mind. How’s business Gordie?
Twitter: Giveabrick
says:
Glad you mentioned that Gordie. That’s what we have over at GAB. We call it ‘look who’s talking this month’
Works well for the reasons you’ve mentioned.
Eleanor Edwards´s last blog ..Why Science Says Happy Works – Dr Egg’s Blog
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
I’ll probably look at doing this once the ‘leader’ board gets too out of control lol
Twitter: allynpaul
says:
Gordie, you are a smart dude! I agree that “subscribing” to comments is very important. It is good for the blog owner too, especially on those posts that get comments for months… someone subscribes to a post last year, and they forget about you.. but then that post gets a new comment and it keeps you in the forefront of your readers minds.
does that make sense?
This means that if you have a post with 100+ comments, then next year, you should go leave a comment on it your-own-self and remind all those people that you are still around and they need to come see you.
Al
Allyn´s last blog ..Dear Chris Brogan
Twitter: KiwiGordie
says:
Exactly, Allyn.
Gordie´s last blog ..You’re A Bad Parent If …
Twitter: SteveYoungs
says:
I disagree with this. It sends you an email for every comment posted, not just followups and replies to your comment. I got sick of deleting the thousands of useless emails I was getting.
But don’t fear! There is an answer.
On my site, if you leave a comment and then somebody replies to your comment, you get notification by email. So you only hear about it if someone has replied to you.
The plugin is called “ReplyMe”
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Reply me, top tip, Thanks steve
Twitter: southrngurl6489
says:
I disagree with you Steve. Unless it’s somewhere that gets hundreds of comments per post, getting those extra emails is no biggie. Plus it allows you to comment on NEW comments that weren’t there when you added your two cents. It helps the conversation grow, and allows you to particapate in all the commenting going on without having to check back a million times to see what everyone is saying.
Both systems have there good and bad sides. I prefer to get all comments, so I can reply to those I find interesting and/or find new people to engage with, blogs to read, etc.
Gurl´s last blog ..Goal Setting: Get It In Writing
Twitter: allynpaul
says:
Yeah, I tried to use ComLuv with Disqus and it broke my shiz, so i don’t think you can.
Anyway, I made my blog DO-Follow so the links are live. Commenters get a link from their “name” which can be a keyword and also from the Com Luv (a deep link).
But I agree, James, your interaction in the comments is really the most important part of the site IMO.
AL
Allyn´s last blog ..Dear Chris Brogan
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey brother, yeah being really active in the comments is the respectfull thing to do, your readers put you there so the least you can do is talk and communicate with them, awesome work on the new site brother
Twitter: kbloemendaal
says:
I detest Disqus or any other app that deters commentors, the more steps they have to take, the less likely a first time commentor will go through with it.
Just curious why your forum will be invitation only?
Keith´s last blog ..Add Feeds To Your Facebook Fan Page
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hi Keith yeah I hear you brother.
he forum is going to be (initally) invitation only because I want serious people there, it’s not going to be high fives and hugs over there, pure business. You’re definately invited brother!
Twitter: kbloemendaal
says:
Looking forward to seeing what it is all about…
Thanks
Keith´s last blog ..Add Feeds To Your Facebook Fan Page
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
I’ll send your invite out soon brother
Twitter: SteveYoungs
says:
Did I skim this article too quickly? What forum? What invite? Where’s mine?
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Steve,
Your invite will be sent out too don’t worry! It’s going to be revealed in a few days
Twitter: freemanlegacy
says:
As the commentators nurture ones site so should one do the same.
I look forward to getting comments more than I do affiliate revenue (I think). there is nothing worse then the feeling that you are speaking to a wall. So, if one wants their readers to return and be active responding and engaging in conversation is paramount.
Ms. Freeman´s last blog ..Why I Welcome Being Laid Off From My Job
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Completely agree, Have you seens Allyn’s Latest post on this subject? Dear Chris Brogan
Twitter: robsellen
says:
Forum?
Won’t be calling it the fourth tribe…will you?
I am amazed how many people out there ignore those who comment on their blogs, all that work to get the attention in the first place, then ignoring it?
That’s just stupid in itself.
Without comments, it’s just a one opinion piece.
Rob
P.s nice blog!

Rob Sellen´s last blog ..The third tribe suckers
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Rob,
Nah don’t worry won’t be anything like that, It’s crazy, honestly crazy when I see people not replying to comments, why on earth don’t they do it? Mental if you ask me, but there you go, maybe I care about the readers… lol
Twitter: robsellen
says:
Care about the readers… how novel! :p
Rob Sellen´s last blog ..The third tribe suckers
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Ha ha good to another with the same mindset brother
Twitter: AgentDeepak
says:
You are very good at attracting comments to your posts. How you do it? I have been here for some day and I see you get lots of comments.
Anyways, when I saw the title I though “LIKE FORUM’. What? but after reading the article. Yeah! thats it. Awesome.
Agent Deepak´s last blog ..Get your Face on Facebook
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Man,
Glad you have been hanging out all day, but make sure you work on your own site too, won’t have any slackers round here lol. I think the key to a load of comments (to pre-empt my new tutorial) is to be active yourself, reply and contribute to, not just your own, but hundreds of other sites. I visit and comment on a lot of different places so I think that helps a lot. I’ve got a free tutorial coming out very soon, keep an eye out for it.
How are you trying to attract comments at the moment?
Twitter: kruby
says:
“You are nothing without your readers and as such you need to look after them. They in turn will look after each other which creates a community. ”
This, I feel, says it all.
Karen
Karen´s last blog ..Why It’s Never Too Late For Your Dreams To Come True
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Karen, yeah me too readers are the life blood of a site.
Twitter: ralphcarlson
says:
I think that a post without comments is like the tree falling in the forrest. Does it have an impact (make a sound) if there is no one there to read (hear) it. Unfortunately, it is unlikely that the kind of readers that wil engage will just find you. You have to look for them and engage and then, maybe, they will notice you. You could be William Shakespeare and it wouldn’t help.
Ralph´s last blog ..What’s in a Name?
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
You’re right Ralph and great analogy, by focusing on building a REAL relationship not one based on lies, you create a real community, which in my opinion is the most important thing for a website.
Twitter: dboguejmatthews
says:
Comments are great. I love the conversation that goes back and forth. I am always excited to read replies to my comments and to get comments on my posts. I like to reply to comments as well. I think that it makes the blogging experience much more personal and interactive; breeding loyalty and word of mouth advertising through the social networks.
Justin
Justin Matthews´s last blog ..Fiction Stories to the Blogosphere, Death With A Vengance pt 1
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Justin,
Yeah you’re right man I think being a personal website rather than a ‘I talk you listen’ type site is the key really
Twitter: cadilacjax
says:
I’ll never forget the first comment that landed on my blog. Bless that gals heart! I would like to think that I would have eventually received a comment from someone, but if not for that first one, I’m not sure I would have not pursued different directions. I couldn’t wait to hurry up and go comment back to her. Someone above mentioned their comments being more valuable to them than adsense or affiliate revenue. Ditto that! I like this blog for the interaction it creates and it has a great community of bloggers who are caring James. It’s always great to see Allyn too and I liked his post about CB.
Nuff Said. Cheers everybody and those who’ll watch the Super Bowl — Go Colts!
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
man we don’t get American Football over here that often… sucks.
Yeah man Allyn is out there rocking it brother but backing it all up and look at the amount of people agreeing, can’t be that far off the mark. Comments are pure gold I love it
Twitter: travisamorgan
says:
Holy cow, there’s tons of comments already. And I love the picture!! That’s hilarious. I don’t know why, but it made me laugh.
Thanks bro, and yes I use CommentLuv.
Travis´s last blog ..The End Justifies the Means
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Commentluv rules, did you see the free tutorial ? check out the page tabs
Twitter: twitter.com/djnuttall
says:
I just came over from Allyn Hane’s blog to see what he was praising you so much for. Now I see!
You are definitely right on about the importance of the comment section of your posts. This to me is exactly what web 2.0 is all about. Too often the blog owners dismiss the comment section of their blogs. This is where I have most of my engaging social networking. I have met some really awesome people in the comment sections of a lot of internet marketers. I can say I have a really great community of online friends and co-workers all of which I found through the comment section.
Denise´s last blog ..How to Make Money Online at Home Has a New Look
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Denise,
You’re absolutely right comments are the life of a site. I hate it when I find a site with no interaction from the owner. It’s really insulting. Thanks Allyn has done be proud over there, FYI your new site design is great
Twitter: cadilacjax
says:
Thanks for sharing that Denise. It’s music to my ears…
Twitter: twitter.com/djnuttall
says:
Thanks for stopping by! You now have one more follower on Twitter. I will definitely be back!
Denise´s last blog ..How to Make Money Online at Home Has a New Look
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Excellent, I’m prolific on twitter just so you know, if it gets too much just remove me on your home feeds. I won’t be offended.
Twitter: robsellen
says:
whatever…

Rob Sellen´s last blog ..The third tribe suckers
Comments gives Social Proof. Its good to track comments using email and RSS feed. With my first guest post in this blog, I forgot to subscribe for email updates. Only a few weeks later I found that there were comments on my post and I haven’t replied to them. I made sure not to make this mistake for my second guest post.
Aaron´s last blog ..Passion vs. Enjoyment
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Aaron,
Yeah replying to guest posts can be especially effective, instead of having one or two links in the post, you now create 10′s of links by replying to every comment
Twitter: theDigitalDoctr
says:
James,
One of the things I love about your blog is the comments. And the way you engage the commentators. Sometimes blogs can feel like a “lecture”, but you always have “conversations”. I love it! Man I hope to get my new blog to that stage one day. It’s more techie I guess so it can get lecture-like, but I really want to have conversations with others. I learn so much that way. Please continue to do what you do. Thanks.
Bryan aka theDigitalDoctr´s last blog ..Does Your Small Business Have a "Digital Identity"?
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Bryan,
Yeah you’ll definately do it man, even thought it’s techie you can still have a conversation in your comments, just continue your post in the comments, what do you think?
Twitter: daltonsbriefs
says:
After the rousing endorsement from Allyn at blogger illustrated I thought it wise to come over and check out your site. Reserving comments for later as I need to read a bit more to get the feel for things around here. Grabbing RSS … will be back.
daltonsbriefs´s last blog ..Northwest Indiana Homes and Mortgages
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey man,
yeah sure have a dig around, if you need anything feel free to shout.
Twitter: Bigredtomato
says:
Until a couple of weeks ago I didn’t really have a ‘forum’ as such, then Karen emailed me and pointed this out. More importantly she showed me which settings I had turned off which once enabled allowed readers to reply to each other and get follow up comments by email.
If the sense of community (I prefer this to forum) didn’t exist here, then I wouldn’t have been able to extend the comunity on my site.
Matthew Needham´s last blog ..Tom beat Blue Monday
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Matthew,
Yeah that’s the great thing about having a community it really does help when you need help or someone can see you need help. Karen is always really helpfull
Twitter: robsellen
says:
Linked to this post… though the commentluv thing on here doesn’t yet show the most recent post.

Rob Sellen´s last blog ..The third tribe suckers
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Rob,
Yeah commentluv has been having problems of late, I have found registering on thier site helps refresh the cache quicker, If you click the tiny red arrow at the right of your commentluv link as you’re adding a comment it will give you more information about it.
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Awesome post of yours brother, just left a comment
Twitter: robsellen
says:
Thanks, commented a reply too…
I will look into that commentluv thing, thanks for letting me know how.
Rob Sellen´s last blog ..The third tribe suckers
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
No problem Rob, mention your post in one I’m publishing tomorrow.
Twitter: robsellen
says:
Went to the commentluv site… got as username… at the least.

Rob Sellen´s last blog ..The third tribe suckers
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Cool, mine took a couple of days to kick in properly
Twitter: JimiJones
says:
James,
this is a great community with plenty of interaction among like-minded individuals. I visit a lot of sites each week and the one thing that I find all too often, is that many leave comments that are open for further conversation, but allow the action to die because they don’t follow-up or return to see if a reply was offered.
Now I’m not being critical or judgmental of anyone (who the heck am I?), I am simply pointing out an observance. I love the conversation myself and can be a chatterbox on occasion (you didn’t have to agree so readily). LOL
But you know what I mean, this is social media so let’s be sociable and not just say “Good post” or some of the other well worn term, leaving it at that and that alone.
Jimi Jones´s last blog ..Should a Blogger Outsource?
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Jimi,
Thanks brother, did you see the latest post about your forum invite?
Twitter: JimiJones
says:
Thanks so much. Over there now.
Jimi Jones´s last blog ..Should a Blogger Outsource?
Twitter: monevator
says:
I worked on a blog once where a particular post freakishly ranked high for an obscure but suddenly popular keyword.
Forum is the only word for what happened next. We ended up with about 300 to 400 comments on there, at least. Maybe twice that, I forget. We had to paginate them in the end!
Monevator´s last blog ..Playing chicken with house prices
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey,
That is a hell of a lot of comments for one post, must have taken an age to read through them all!
Yes – comments make a blog look alive. So comment on – and very impressive comment numbers – WOW.
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Hey Jade, thanks the people here are like a really tight family network.
While I like to think of my comment section as a mini-forum, I’ve actually been debating quite a bit about creating a full-fledged forum on my blog for a specific course I’m running. I love to foster communication when possible and believe that creating an even closer community via a forum fosters more communication as well.
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
That sounds like a good idea, I love the way forums work, the forum for this site is going well and the sense of community is fantastic
I have started a blog and have a 100 subscribers. But yet to build a forum around the blog. Good I read this article. Thanks
Ganapathy´s last blog ..A committed professional
Twitter: JarrodLClark
says:
I love comments and I do see the importance of having a community at the end of a post. There is something about a new blog that I find, that has a load of comments on it. That says life to me.
The lively hood of your blog increases when there is a lot of community interaction. One of the things I look for when I find a new blog that helps me determine the credibility of it is the interaction between the readers AND the author.
Great post and thanks for sharing!
Twitter: theinfopreneur
says:
Yeah having interaction is awesome and you’re right it builds the strength of the site, the comments only improve the quality of the post
Twitter: darrenlcarter
says:
Hey James,
Another great post. I actually went and put a top commentors plugin on my blog right after I read your recommendation! Thanks.
Peace,
Darren L Carter
Darren L Carter´s last blog ..Why You Should Jump Off A Cliff…